Metal Sludge Gossip Board

How the two compare in the playoffs:

Manning
9-10 record
1-1 in Superbowl


Dilfer
5-1 record
1-0 in Superbowl


Hard to argue with the facts. Dilfer outperformed Manning when the games mattered most.

SkyDog112046 wrote:How the two compare in the playoffs:

Manning
9-10 record
1-1 in Superbowl


Dilfer
5-1 record
1-0 in Superbowl


Hard to argue with the facts. Dilfer outperformed Manning when the games mattered most.

Oh come on dude. Now you're just being ridiculous.

Looking for a QB in Carolina, and every now and then you'll hear some idiot say "You don't need an elite quarterback to win a Super Bowl. Just look at Trent Dilfer". Yep. All we need to do is get a defense as good as the 2000 Ravens. No problem.

Dilfer came from a better college also

Dilfer was ACTUALLY a hot commodity when he was drafted - to fill the gap of the legendary Vinny Testaverde in Tampa.

bane wrote:Oh come on dude. Now you're just being ridiculous.

Ever hear the saying "rubbing salt into the wound"?

Granted, P13 probably has taken dozens of loads all over his pimply face so he is used to it, but still.

SkyDog112046 wrote:

bane wrote:Oh come on dude. Now you're just being ridiculous.

Ever hear the saying "rubbing salt into the wound"?

Granted, P13 probably has taken dozens of loads all over his pimply face so he is used to it, but still.

Facts are facts.

HMJ wrote:Dilfer was ACTUALLY a hot commodity when he was drafted - to fill the gap of the legendary Vinny Testaverde in Tampa.

I'm pretty sure it was he and Heath Shuler who were the top 2 QBs taken that draft.

HMJ wrote:Dilfer was ACTUALLY a hot commodity when he was drafted - to fill the gap of the legendary Vinny Testaverde in Tampa.

Subtract Vinny's Tampa years from his stat card and you actually have damned solid QB. Look at what happened to Doug Williams and Steve Young once they got out of there! That place was QB purgatory for nearly 20 years dude.

SkyDog112046 wrote:How the two compare in the playoffs:

Manning
9-10 record
1-1 in Superbowl


Dilfer
5-1 record
1-0 in Superbowl


Hard to argue with the facts. Dilfer outperformed Manning when the games mattered most.

Crazy Levi wrote:

HMJ wrote:Dilfer was ACTUALLY a hot commodity when he was drafted - to fill the gap of the legendary Vinny Testaverde in Tampa.

I'm pretty sure it was he and Heath Shuler who were the top 2 QBs taken that draft.

Haha so you mentioned Shuler and I wikipedia'd him...

He is in the god damn U.S. House of Representatives now for North Carolina!

Your hard on for P13 is almost as annoying as his hard on for Manning. Don't you have some weights to lift Lickety?

SkyDog112046 wrote:How the two compare in the playoffs:

Manning
9-10 record
1-1 in Superbowl


Dilfer
5-1 record
1-0 in Superbowl


Hard to argue with the facts. Dilfer outperformed Manning when the games mattered most.

Joe Flacco has 4 road wins in the playoffs.

Redman77 wrote:Your hard on for P13 is almost as annoying as his hard on for Manning. Don't you have some weights to lift Lickety?

Agreed. It's time for both of them to just fuck off into the sunset.

Holy Christ I hope the Pats lose.

Crazy Levi wrote: Holy Christ I hope the Pats lose.

Hey now! There are some decent Pats fans in here!

WTF wrote:

Crazy Levi wrote: Holy Christ I hope the Pats lose.

Hey now! There are some decent Pats fans in here!

I don't think I've seen any Patriots fans on here talking trash about New England winning anything this year.

HMJ wrote:

Crazy Levi wrote:

HMJ wrote:Dilfer was ACTUALLY a hot commodity when he was drafted - to fill the gap of the legendary Vinny Testaverde in Tampa.

I'm pretty sure it was he and Heath Shuler who were the top 2 QBs taken that draft.

Haha so you mentioned Shuler and I wikipedia'd him...

He is in the god damn U.S. House of Representatives now for North Carolina!

At least he's a Democrat.

MurrayFiend wrote:
At least he's a Democrat.

He's a Blue Dog Democrat.

Oh, well... fuck him with his gun, then.

MurrayFiend wrote:Oh, well... fuck him with his gun, then.