Metal Sludge Gossip Board

Just as it says. Who's the best QB in your opinion?

I'd create a poll but I guess that option isn't available in the locker room.

They're both HOF QBs. Doesn't matter.

johnk5150 wrote:They're both HOF QBs. Doesn't matter.

As a Patriots fan since 1975, and a Brady nutswinger since 2001, I agree. I love Manning and his thumb-head. Solidified by his SNL performances.

I have to say that I like Brady moving around in and out of the pocket the last couple weeks. A nice addition and he's been pretty accurate while moving.

Brady, of course.

matter's if you are a Patriots fan vs Colts

3 vs 1
11-5


always hated Manning in college and pros

thanks for the 8 points

from a non fan of both players, Brady is most fun to see

johnk5150 wrote:They're both HOF QBs. Doesn't matter.

Does indeed matter.
Count the number of SB wins for Brady and count the
number for Manning.
BIG DIFFERENCE!!!

What's the use of putting up a great stats during the reg. season when
the same player can not produce when it matters the most?

Something I don't understand is the "head to head" numbers. Folks always want to throw that up but don't you think it's a bit of an unfair stat?

I mean, the two of them aren't facing one another. Manning against the Pats defense is the focus. Brady against the Colts or Broncos D in the same way. The teams do...but not the qb's. It's a debatable argument though.

And the Superbowl comparison can be broken down too. Not going to argue that Brady is an excellent qb...but Eli has two rings and beat the Pats both times. Anyone want to say that Eli is better than Peyton? Farve went to two SB's and only has one ring. Marino has none. You have to view that based on the team's overall strength...not single out the quarterback.

That said, I'd say it's 55/45 Manning.

Too close to call in many ways, but Brady seems to have done a whole more with a whole lot less in terms of receivers and offensive playmakers. So, I give him the slight edge.

That said, I have to say until the past few weeks, I thought Manning looked a lot better than Brady was convinced that Manning had maintained form better than Brady. Looks like I was very wrong.

Wouldn't the ability to execute "in the clutch" or when it matters be kind of the deciding factor? They're both great QBs, but Brady hasn't surpassed Bret Favre with the most playoff losses in NFL history. Manning owns that shit.

Wasn't that the main thing said about Montana? With a couple seconds left when it matters he'll make the play ( Dallas/Cincy, etc. ). Peyton's ability to read defenses and all that is unparalleled. Manning's ability to dominate when it matters isn't.

If I was a coach I would give the ball to his retarded little brother in the big game before him. Brady wins.

killeverything wrote:Wouldn't the ability to execute "in the clutch" or when it matters be kind of the deciding factor? They're both great QBs, but Brady hasn't surpassed Bret Favre with the most playoff losses in NFL history. Manning owns that shit.

Wasn't that the main thing said about Montana? With a couple seconds left when it matters he'll make the play ( Dallas/Cincy, etc. ). Peyton's ability to read defenses and all that is unparalleled. Manning's ability to dominate when it matters isn't.

If I was a coach I would give the ball to his retarded little brother in the big game before him. Brady wins.

You nailed it Kill. Eli is much more clutch compared to Peyton. Does not matter what happens during the reg. season, just matters when the game is on the line or during the biggest game of the season(Playoffs & Super Bowl)

Joe Montana smokes them both.

AliceManson wrote:Joe Montana smokes them both.

Stick to the subject, LOL!!!

No need to drag Joe into the convo.

Brady.. All Day. Every Football Game Day.

Machado wrote: You nailed it Kill. Eli is much more clutch compared to Peyton. Does not matter what happens during the reg. season

It matters when you consider the fact that Eli is about to miss the playoffs for the 5th time in the last 6 years.

Tenacious_Dio wrote:

Machado wrote: You nailed it Kill. Eli is much more clutch compared to Peyton. Does not matter what happens during the reg. season

It matters when you consider the fact that Eli is about to miss the playoffs for the 5th time in the last 6 years.

Peyton can put up all the numbers he wants during the reg season.
Peyton can break all the records but it does not matter if the guy cannot lead
his team to a SB victory.

Righ now baby bro has more than Peyton. Isn't that what matters the most???

Machado wrote:

Tenacious_Dio wrote:

Machado wrote: You nailed it Kill. Eli is much more clutch compared to Peyton. Does not matter what happens during the reg. season

It matters when you consider the fact that Eli is about to miss the playoffs for the 5th time in the last 6 years.

Peyton can put up all the numbers he wants during the reg season.
Peyton can break all the records but it does not matter if the guy cannot lead
his team to a SB victory.

Righ now baby bro has more than Peyton. Isn't that what matters the most???

You're the dumbest poster here. Goddamn.

The one who steps up in the biggest games, plays like a champ and don't choke. That leaves manning delivering papa johns.

Every offense Peyton has been on has been loaded of hall of fame RB's and WR's that he played with for years and years gaining all that timing and gelling.

Brady has won with all sorts of different players. He's had weapons as well but every year it's a different RB and WR core. The Pat's were never afraid to get rid of a player as long as they had Brady.

With that said, I love watching Peyton in the regular season tear apart a team like General Patton. One of the best ever who happens to be able to choke. And whines when he over throws, or fucks up a pass, blaming it on someone else. Still one of the best I've ever seen regardless.

Roth or Hagar?

MurrayFiend wrote:

Machado wrote: Right now baby bro has more than Peyton. Isn't that what matters the most???

You're the dumbest poster here. Goddamn.

turn the page. you are a broken record

Machado wrote:

Tenacious_Dio wrote:

Machado wrote: You nailed it Kill. Eli is much more clutch compared to Peyton. Does not matter what happens during the reg. season

It matters when you consider the fact that Eli is about to miss the playoffs for the 5th time in the last 6 years.

Peyton can put up all the numbers he wants during the reg season.
Peyton can break all the records but it does not matter if the guy cannot lead
his team to a SB victory.

Righ now baby bro has more than Peyton. Isn't that what matters the most???

I'll take a guy who's had 14 great years over a guy who's had 3 or 4.

They are both HOFs. It doesn't matter.

johnk5150 wrote:They are both HOFs. It doesn't matter.

Roth or Hagar? Hagar had the #1 songs and albums. Roth has choked on a few things but still helped create VH.

UtahRatt wrote:Hagar had the #1 songs

"Jump" is Van Halen's only #1 song.

Tenacious_Dio wrote:

UtahRatt wrote:Hagar had the #1 songs

"Jump" is Van Halen's only #1 song.

That song sucked and it depends on what board.

Why Can't This Be Love - Album Rock Tracks #1
Black n Blue and When it's love - Mainstream Rock Tracks #1
FUCK had three songs go number one! On Album rock tracks!

So that clearly proves Brady and Hagar is better. More #1 albums, songs and SB!

UtahRatt wrote:

Tenacious_Dio wrote:

UtahRatt wrote:Hagar had the #1 songs

"Jump" is Van Halen's only #1 song.

That song sucked and it depends on what board.

Why Can't This Be Love - Album Rock Tracks #1
Black n Blue and When it's love - Mainstream Rock Tracks #1
FUCK had three songs go number one! On Album rock tracks!

So that clearly proves Brady and Hagar is better. More #1 albums, songs and SB!

They're both Rock N' Roll Hall Of Famers. It doesn't matter.

Brady

I will be at Brady V Luck next Sunday. Should be entertaining.

Say hi to p13.