*POLL* Do you believe Hagar when he says he made up with EVH before he died?

[JamesHetfieldsAcneScars]

.


If you had to guess, do you think he really did?


.

[Brainy Lane]

I don’t think so. I like Sammy, but you just can’t believe a word he says.

[Tenacious_Dio]

I believe they exchanged a couple of texts, but that's about it.

[NeonKnite]

The story changed every time he told it. Sam is the definition of an unreliable narrator.

So yeah. Maybe a few texts. Sam said that originally. Then it changed to video calls. Then it changed to Ed telling him he wanted to write songs with him. Then after he died he was visiting him in a dream and writing a song with him.

Sammy originally said they never talked music, then later on it changed to writing songs.

The guy is a pathological liar.

[FreddyFender]

I'm just waiting for the day where Sam starts saying that Ed's final words were him telling Sammy that "Eagles Fly" was the best song ever written, and real reason their relationship was strained because Ed was jealous that he didn't write it.

[Tommy2Tone84]

I'm just waiting for the day where Sam starts saying that Ed's final words were him telling Sammy that "Eagles Fly" was the best song ever written, and real reason their relationship was strained because Ed was jealous that he didn't write it.

Ed did and said some crazy and weird shit. I could see him saying something like this.

[greengoblinrulz]

His story is too convenient & no way to check it
Hagar is the type of guy who would've been blurting it out the next day & he didnt
You know Sammy is full of shit anytime his lips move

[SterileEyes1]

Say what you want about WVH, he has shown himself to be more than capable of publicly calling out bullshit. I really doubt he’d abide Sammy lying about his dad like that, much less be cordial when they’ve run into each other in recent years.

[rockker]

Say what you want about WVH, he has shown himself to be more than capable of publicly calling out bullshit. I really doubt he’d abide Sammy lying about his dad like that, much less be cordial when they’ve run into each other in recent years.

This.

Hagar is full of shit 99% of the time, but there is no way Wolfgang would let a bullshit story about his beloved “Pops” fly without shutting it down. In this instance I think Hagar is telling the truth

[HoldenSSV]

I believe he made an honest effort, not sure how Eddie responded.

[ParaDime77]

No.

Al has completely froze Sammy out of mentions in his book. Plus, shut down any tribute show advances. Agreed, there may have been a text or two from both parties, but making up is all fluff.

Eddie Trunk begging to his viewers on his radio show for answers as to why Al won’t talk with Sammy is pure comedy. Van Han Halen as a brand with its songs will last a lifetime longer than Sammy Hagar,

[FreddyFender]

I think making the assumption that Wolf ended up with Ed’s phone, and that he went through it to see if Ed had been texting with Sam, is a serious reach.

Just as likely his wife (or Val) ended up with it, and threw it in the trash because his camera roll was just porn clips he’d downloaded.

[daveg]

I don't think Sammy is making stuff up. I think he actually believes all the crazy shit he says

[kanister]

Say what you want about WVH, he has shown himself to be more than capable of publicly calling out bullshit. I really doubt he’d abide Sammy lying about his dad like that, much less be cordial when they’ve run into each other in recent years.

This.

Hagar is full of shit 99% of the time, but there is no way Wolfgang would let a bullshit story about his beloved “Pops” fly without shutting it down. In this instance I think Hagar is telling the truth

His silence would also mean that the supposed contact between Sam and Ed was minimal.

[greengoblinrulz]

Say what you want about WVH, he has shown himself to be more than capable of publicly calling out bullshit. I really doubt he’d abide Sammy lying about his dad like that, much less be cordial when they’ve run into each other in recent years.

Obviously unless Wolfie and/or Al had no knowledge of this happenning as Sammy hasnt specified when this happened. Sam also conveniently didnt go public with this till after Edwards death That is Sammy PR 101, do something that nobody can prove wrong.