NeonKnite wrote: ↑Sun Jan 19, 2025 1:10 pm
DemonFilth2001 wrote: ↑Sun Jan 19, 2025 9:36 am
Tommy is correct on a lot here. Revenge is one of their worst non makeup releases. Unholy is good. Domino was ok. Guess the ballad was good for what it was. CN wasn’t good. But still better overall than Revenge, Hot, COS, and Unmasked.
Nah, you're wrong too.
Revenge is vastly better than HITS and CN which are two of the biggest turds in their catalog. I'd say it has
more great songs than ASYLUM or Animalize though it has a few absolute stinkers ("I Just Wanna", "Everytime I Look At You") and a few "eh" songs ("Heart of Chrome", "Spit") where those albums pull closer when they're judged on the whole. I don't get why people don't like "Domino". I've always love that song and it should have been the 2nd single as planned, but Paul was such a bitch they had to release IJW. With GGRARTY2 released in 1991, followed by "Unholy", Kiss was getting some cred back. "Domino" would have continued that momentum because being in college at that time, I knew non-Kiss fans that like that song. IJW brought the momentum to a screeching halt.
In regard to sales for Revenge, you can throw that out the window. First off, we were in the grunge era and second, they had released two such god awful albums in a row that it was gonna take more than one album to get people back. Similar to COTN.
Demon is spot on here even if we don’t totally agree on the details
Most of us were in college at the time, There was alot of hype and MTV showed it a lot of love.
But when you threw the cassette in the deck it fell flat. Solid playing and admittedly, some of the
best production, but the songs weren’t there. To top it off, you had both Gene and Paul claiming
there were no lyrics about strippers, sluts and sex. Then you throw it in the deck and you hear
lyrics that make X In Sex sound like Sympathy for the Devil.
No need to make excuses. Non makeup and non original lineups had flat sales and uneven attendance during that time.
Figuring out the fickleness of KISS fans is something I finally gave up on. I can’t figure out why Animalize and Crazy Nights sold more copies than Creatures, Lick It Up and Asylum.
I can’t figure out how Crazy Nights went platinum but the tour was allegedly an abysmal failure. The shows I’ve seen from Tokyo to Western Europe to Stateside seem to prove otherwise. But the tour doesn’t have quite the enthusiasm
that the Asylum shows did.
Fans shit talk Asylum but it went gold and every audience bootleg I’ve heard and seen from that tour, the arena crowds are rabid, LOUD and going absolutely insane for the band, from the Garden in NYC to Cobo Hall in Detroit to Cleveland to Dallas. But fans claim it was sparsely attended and a bust of a tour. Judging by audience reaction, Asylum seems like one of the more successful tours they did from 1980 to 1995. They played from coast to coast whereas Revenge seemed more like the Creatures tour and later
Psycho Circus tour. Lackluster and lethargic
The Reunion proved fans and the public at large wanted the originals back. I didn’t necessarily. I liked the non makeup era. I was one of the few who missed it when it was gone. I wasn’t surprised when the originals fell apart again. It was inevitable. They all wanted to pad or have a retirement. I didn’t blame them.