Is Shinedown REAL Rock? (Poll)

Rocker4Real · Post by **Rocker4Real** » Sat Aug 02, 2025 6:09 am

Is Shinedown REAL Rock?

Wild Obsession · Post by **Wild Obsession** » Sat Aug 02, 2025 6:57 am

Pop band with guitars. Singer is great, but aside from "Second Chance", everything I have heard has been forgettable/generic.

pieceofme · Post by **pieceofme** » Sat Aug 02, 2025 8:35 am

Yeah of course it is rock music. Not one I enjoy. But they sound more "rock" than a lot of the bands discussed here frequently.

Traxan · Post by **Traxan** » Sat Aug 02, 2025 4:07 pm

Their first two albums had a great southern rock feel. their cover of "Simple Man" is tremendous. "The Sound of Madness" is brilliant, and "Amarylis" had some moments. After that it became formulaic.

Anyone who voted they have no soul needs to listen to this:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZblazK4PcJk

And Brent belongs in the pantheon of great rock singers.

JourneyRules · Post by **JourneyRules** » Sat Aug 02, 2025 5:50 pm

Traxan wrote: ↑Sat Aug 02, 2025 4:07 pm Anyone who voted they have no soul needs to listen to this:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZblazK4PcJk

One of my absolute favorite Shinedown songs, despite it not being one of their popular ones.

JourneyRules · Post by **JourneyRules** » Sat Aug 02, 2025 5:59 pm

I'm taking my 8 and 12 year old kids to see Shinedown in a few weeks.

Are they a bit more commercial than I would like? Yeah, sure. Have they crossed over a bit too far into the pop territory? Probably.

But they are a good band with a great singer and very good songs.

Post by **Metal Sludge** » Sat Aug 02, 2025 6:06 pm

I saw them at NAMM in 2013. It was a really good show.
They are one of those bands that I didn't think I knew well, but I knew better than I thought?
I definitely enjoyed that show more than I expected to.

Mojo · Post by **Mojo** » Sun Aug 03, 2025 7:22 am

What is "REAL Rock?"

LAglamrocker · Post by **LAglamrocker** » Sun Aug 03, 2025 7:48 am

If I was 12 I would like them
My great great grandparent’s cassette collection would be better with Judas Priest-Iron Maiden-Motorhead- AC DC collection

Fat_Elvis · Post by **Fat_Elvis** » Sun Aug 03, 2025 10:55 am

I'm seeing them tonight with Bush. I'll vote after.

Zander Kelly · Post by **Zander Kelly** » Sun Aug 03, 2025 11:40 am

"Leave A Whisper" was great in it's original form, not the re released version. After that they've been eh. Like most bands, they blew their wad with that first album. They are now just a pop band.

Wild Obsession · Post by **Wild Obsession** » Sun Aug 03, 2025 2:40 pm

Mojo wrote: ↑Sun Aug 03, 2025 7:22 am What is "REAL Rock?"

If you have to ask, you won't understand.

ParaDime77 · Post by **ParaDime77** » Sun Aug 03, 2025 6:37 pm

A great singer and very good songwriting. Band could even be better if the lead singer sang live for at least a portion of the show and guitars Zach Myers shut his mouth on social media. His ego has put the band in bad light for quite a while.

Tommy2Tone84 · Post by **Tommy2Tone84** » Sun Aug 03, 2025 9:25 pm

Mojo wrote: ↑Sun Aug 03, 2025 7:22 am What is "REAL Rock?"

All the 80s rock and metal bands from Van Halen, Ozzy and Scorpions to Cinderella, Skid Row and Trixter.

Fat_Elvis · Post by **Fat_Elvis** » Sun Aug 03, 2025 11:46 pm

I enjoyed the show. Lots of pyro, which I'm a sucker for. And the singer sounds great. I didn't get lip-syncing vibes if that's what was being suggested.

Tourettes · Post by **Tourettes** » Mon Aug 04, 2025 11:35 am

Traxan wrote: ↑Sat Aug 02, 2025 4:07 pm "The Sound of Madness" is brilliant, and "Amarylis" had some moments. After that it became formulaic.

Exactly my feelings.

LAglamrocker · Post by **LAglamrocker** » Mon Aug 04, 2025 11:47 am

world voted - not real rock

pyro should be banned for Sh*tdown
Cody Rhodes likes Shinedown
Seth Rollins laughs at Shinedown

#TrixterIsRealRock

exitflagger · Post by **exitflagger** » Tue Aug 05, 2025 12:38 pm

That guy's voice is horrifying.

JourneyRules · Post by **JourneyRules** » Tue Aug 05, 2025 1:41 pm

Fat_Elvis wrote: ↑Sun Aug 03, 2025 11:46 pm I enjoyed the show. Lots of pyro, which I'm a sucker for. And the singer sounds great. I didn't get lip-syncing vibes if that's what was being suggested.

Yeah, that's one I've never heard before. If it is being suggested they use backing tracks, well, yeah, they openly admitted to that. But the lead vocals are live.

ParaDime77 · Post by **ParaDime77** » Tue Aug 05, 2025 3:38 pm

JourneyRules wrote: ↑Tue Aug 05, 2025 1:41 pm
Fat_Elvis wrote: ↑Sun Aug 03, 2025 11:46 pm I enjoyed the show. Lots of pyro, which I'm a sucker for. And the singer sounds great. I didn't get lip-syncing vibes if that's what was being suggested.
Yeah, that's one I've never heard before. If it is being suggested they use backing tracks, well, yeah, they openly admitted to that. But the lead vocals are live.

Not all the vocals are live. A lot of help involved.

HottKarl777 · Post by **HottKarl777** » Tue Aug 05, 2025 4:16 pm

His version is Simple Man is overwrought. I liked him better fat for some reason.