Anything (music-related) we can ALL agree on? (...or most of us)

[daveg]

No one here will ever agree on anything.

Oh no u did not just say that. NoI did not Please unalive yoself

If we can't all agree that VH3 is thier worst album, then society is over as we knew it

[Chip Z'Hoy]

No one here will ever agree on anything.

Oh no u did not just say that. NoI did not Please unalive yoself

If we can't all agree that VH3 is thier worst album, then society is over as we knew it

I think we might see some ADKoT votes there, unfortunately.

I don't understand either. We live in a broken society.

[RicksPickWrangler]

"I prefer to listen to Cheap Trick" - Homer Simpson

[BulletProofPoet]

Anyone think Jellyfish weren’t phenomenal?

[Anthrax442]

I think we might see some ADKoT votes there, unfortunately.

I don't understand either. We live in a broken society.

You're probably correct, but I can't imagine a world, where someone with ears that function, thinks that VHIII is better than ADKOT.

[Hair I Go Again]

Maybe this will unite us?

[Chip Z'Hoy]

Maybe this will unite us?

Airheads or Lemmy? I'm on board with both, big time.

I'm 45 years old and probably make an Airheads reference once a week. "You wanna take a step back? You're standing on my DICK, man!"

[woblinweebles]

I think we might see some ADKoT votes there, unfortunately.

I don't understand either. We live in a broken society.

You're probably correct, but I can't imagine a world, where someone with ears that function, thinks that VHIII is better than ADKOT.

I'm sure there are some Extreme fans who prefer or Hagar-era fans that take their Sammy VS Dave debate seriously.

[Chip Z'Hoy]

Anyone think Jellyfish weren’t phenomenal?

This is interesting. I think we might have a consensus on Jellyfish.

Fellow rockers? How are we on Jellyfish.

[HueyRamone]

Master of Puppets is Metallica's best album.

Nope, its a slog to get through. RTL is the best. And I dont really like the MOP title track.

Sorry to be THAT guy.

[LAglamrocker]

Motley Crue pizza is best idea since topless maids(female)

[Chip Z'Hoy]

topless maids(female)

[Aerosmith87]

I always figured Motorhead, AC/DC for the Sludge crowed would universally enjoyed and if not respected. Then for the lighter guys Cheap Trick.... for the poppier boys Weezer.

[Anthrax442]

I think we might see some ADKoT votes there, unfortunately.

I don't understand either. We live in a broken society.

You're probably correct, but I can't imagine a world, where someone with ears that function, thinks that VHIII is better than ADKOT.

I'm sure there are some Extreme fans who prefer or Hagar-era fans that take their Sammy VS Dave debate seriously.

I like Extreme. Not sure I'd call myself a fan, but I think they've got some pretty good songs.

If you rated VHIII along with all six Extreme albums, VHIII would be seventh. It's that bad.

[Anthrax442]

Master of Puppets is Metallica's best album.

Nope, its a slog to get through. RTL is the best. And I dont really like the MOP title track.

Sorry to be THAT guy.

That's interesting. To me, the slog album is Justice. Just song after song of 7 to 10 minute tracks. At least the lengthier songs on MOP went somewhere.

I won't argue RTL though, I think I probably have that as my number 2.

[Van Ailin']

Anyone think Jellyfish weren’t phenomenal?

No. They were superb, live and studio.

[Van Ailin']

We can all agree that:

1) Mike Slamer was Warrant's best guitarist

2) Steve Perry was better before the age of 50

3) Yngwie Malmsteen was better with Jeff Scott Soto

4) Lori Maddox was a huge risk. Rodney should have warned him.

[Wiseacre]

Master of Puppets is Metallica's best album.

Nope, its a slog to get through. RTL is the best. And I dont really like the MOP title track.

Sorry to be THAT guy.

100% RTL was always my favorite. AJFA is pretty unlistenable

[Rocker4Real]

Operation: Mindcrime is a great album.

Meh. If you never heard the wall or read 1984

Although the Beatles are nearly universally loved and/or respected you always have a few “they sucked” boneheads.

They were bigger than the Stones (and I never actually bought a Stones ticket or album), but I don’t know if I’ve ever heard anyone say they sucked at least in their better years. Can we all agree they were fantastic at what they did/do and are the quintessential RnR band?

I was never into Pink Floyd or The Who, so Mindcrime is a top tier Rock Opera. It's rare that I've heard an 80s Rock fan say they don't like it unless they just don't like Ryche.

[Chip Z'Hoy]

It's rare that I've heard an 80s Rock fan say they don't like it unless they just don't like Ryche.

I didn't like it for the longest time. I didn't like QR as a kid or really any of the "operatic" bands. Just didn't have a fun vibe, and I was a little kid.

I know I talk a lot about weed on here these days but when I started smoking on the reg 4-5 years ago I put on Mindcrime and was like "This is great!" (Unrelated to weed, I got really into Rush starting in my late 20's so that lubed me up for the Ryche.)

I still think it sounds like total shit, and the story is silly, but the tunes are just killer.

I'm not a huge QR fan now but I really like that Rage through Promised Land run.

[BulletProofPoet]

Anyone think Jellyfish weren’t phenomenal?

No. They were superb, live and studio.

For the record, I was saying they were awesome! In case that wasn’t clear.

[Metal Sludge]

Have never seen any hate for A-ha's Take on Me

Let me just say, that I'm not hating on it now. I get how they were innovative.
But back in 1985-86, I did hate it. I hated most of the pop music on MTV.
However, there were a few that I loved.
Eddie Murphy, Party All The Time
Phil Collins, Land of Confusion
Whitney Houston, How Will I Know, and I Wanna Dance With Somebody
Oh and, Sting, Russians.

[Ozzy Stradlin]

Three words:

Appetite For Destruction

[Van Ailin']

Anyone think Jellyfish weren’t phenomenal?

No. They were superb, live and studio.

For the record, I was saying they were awesome! In case that wasn’t clear.

And I meant, "no - no one will disagree with that."

[Wiseacre]

Three words:

Appetite For Destruction

No

[SchenkerFan]

Does anyone like Nitro? I've been here for 20 years and I don't remember anyone ever saying they were good.

[SchenkerFan]

How about the first Badlands album? I don't know if it's universally liked here, but it's got to be close. I've been posting here for 25 years (which boggles my mind, but that's a whole different story) and can't recall this album ever getting any kind of significant hate.

I like it, but I think it's massively overrated. It's not a masterpiece by any means. The first half of it maybe. Second half is much weaker.